Parallel Working Group 3: The 8th Asia Forest Partnership (AFP) Meeting
and Dialogue REDD and Combating Illegal Logging
Melia Bali Hotel, Nusa Dua, Bali
Friday, 29 May 2009, 13.30 – 16.30
Organized by CIFOR
Moderator: Elena Petkova
Speakers: Agus P. Sari (Ecosecurities Indonesia), Rodney Taylor (WWF
International), Vincent van den Berk (FLEGT-EU), Bambang Setiono (CIFOR).
Total participants: 37 people (list attached), representing international
organizations (e.g., the World Bank, the EU_FLEGT, others), national governments
(e.g. the Indonesian Ministry of Forestry), donors (e.g. DFID), universities (e.g
Bogor Agricultural University), private companies (e.g. Ecosecurities) and
regional and Indonesian NGOs (e.g. List one).
Presentation 1:
Agus Sari (Ecosecurities)
Agus Sari delivered his presentation on Business Attitudes toward Forest Carbon:
Relevance to REDD. His presentation was based on a 2009 global survey of 143
companies with more 2000 employees.
He presented how companies in North America, Europe and the rest of the world
interested in forest carbon. For companies from North America, they are willing
to buy carbon in higher price than Europe. The summary from the results: most of
respondents gave positive response on forest carbon. Meanwhile in Europe there
is a long history conflict between government and NGOs about forest carbon.
Some reasons that current market dynamics become downturn i.e. economic crisis
reduces demand in everything, voluntary market has been the hardest hit due to
budget cuts among corporate buyers, liquidity problem affects project
development in Indonesia, decreased price of oil, coal, and reduction of exports
further affect carbon market in Indonesia. But economic downturn is relatively
temporary.
Presentation 2:
Rodney Taylor (WWF International)
His presentation was on the role of financial institutions in promoting
sustainability in the forest sector. There are some reasons why financial sector
interested to NGO (in SFM): Huge range of financial services, High impact on the
environment, Leaders are already changing, The Global Crisis. Risks of financing
forest sector projects with poor environmental safeguards: operational risks,
compliance risks, reputation risks.
Some challenges in matching policy and practice are adapting global policies to
local realities, building front office implementation on capacity, retaining
customers when competitors don’t ask the same questions, easier to stay away
than risk involvement in a controversial sector to finance change, transparency
gives ammunition to campaigners – open banks attract more criticism than worst
offenders.
Deforestation rates accelerate as agriculture and other economic activities
replace forests. The natural capital of land and standing timber are exploited.
Eventually, this trend reverses as forests become scarce and rural populations
find work in cities and factories, often linked to a massive growth in
industrial carbon emissions.
Degraded and idle land is mobilized, and agricultural yields improved, to
alleviate poverty, reduce trade imbalances, and improve food security.
Plantation forestry on degraded or marginal land supplies pulp, timber, fuelwood
and/or biomass for renewable energy. Standing and restored natural forests are
managed for carbon storage, ecosystem services, subsistence needs of forest
dependant peoples and/or sustainable extraction of timber and other products.
The new climate deal will shape future financial products in the forest sector
Current options : 1. reward the existence of standing forest carbon, 2. reward
avoided emissions with a reference level based on historical deforestation
rates, combine elements of (1) and (2) (challenge: complexity), 4. reward
avoided emissions with a reference level based on forecast deforestation
scenarios.
Financial institutions can support low carbon development paths depends on laws,
policies and governance at country level, the usual enabling conditions for SFM.
Presentation 3:
Vincent van den Berk (FLEGT-EU)
His presentation was on REDD from a FLEGT VPA perspective. He mentioned that in
the REDD context EU climate change aims to limiting climate change to 2°C above
pre-industrial level. There are demand and supply sides that drives the
deforestation and forest degradation such as good governance timber and forestry
sector, enforcement regulatory framework, lack of market incentives, etc.
EU FLEGT Action Plan combines supply and demands side measures like: Voluntary
Partnership Agreement supported by EU legislation to exclude illegal timber from
the EU market, development cooperation, generating demand through public
procurement policies, promoting certification and labeling, support private
sector initiatives and CITES/UNFF/ITTO. VPA’s support in financial and technical
support to develop and implement a VPA, generate FLEGT licensed timber demand on
the EU market/create market incentives, promote FLEGT approach in other consumer
market and REDD.
Asian countries like Cambodia, Laos, Vietnam, Thailand are REDD countries
candidates in the World Bank Forest Carbon Partnership Facility (WB FCPF),
Vietnam is a pilot country of UNREDD, Malaysia and Indonesia negotiating a VPA,
etc.
FLEGT and REDD share many common elements, one of those elements is REDD is an
additional incentive for entering into a VPA.
Presentation 4:
Bambang Setiono (CIFOR)
His presentation was on ILEA and REDD. ILEA model is a governance and law
enforcement model designed to promote good governance in the forestry sector.
ILEA control the money from the forest. He explains some numbers of
deforestation in Indonesia based on some sources like Forest Planning Agency and
ELSDA Institute; and numbers of wealth from forests in year 2006 to 2008. He
also mention some major drivers of deforestation i.e. land clearing for oil palm
and coal mining, overcapacity of wood based industry, lack of local job
opportunities, local government autonomy and lack of financial integrity.
Besides that, he was mentioned some cases in forestry crimes.
ILEA and REDD, it can relate in monitoring carbon with internal control unit,
auditing unit and accountability unit; in carbon market also with internal
control unit, auditing unit, accountability unit, prudential banking unit; in
payment distribution with auditing unit, accountability unit, prudential banking
unit and law enforcement unit.
The presentations were followed by lively and productive discussion. Main points
that emerged from the discussion were:
• Companies and individuals express motivation and willingness to invest in REDD
schemes because of their potential for biodiversity conservation and improvement
of livelihoods. It is unclear how far they will act on this, but the fact that
livelihoods and biodiversity have high value for them may support REDD. However
there are regional differences between Europe, the USA and other regions and
these should be taking into account by a forest carbon market.
• There is a lot of synergy between incentives which encourage responsible
behavior and REDD. In relation to the demand for timber products, demand for
pulp is projected to rapidly expand in Asia. In order to maximize the tools we
are using to strengthen REDD we need to consider expanding the range of forest
products covered under VPA.
• The oil palm market has a significant impact on deforestation and the REDD
implementation, where carbon profit cannot compete with the profit that comes
from oil palm market. It is a dilemma that needs to be examined more carefully.
Regarding the problem of oil palm in Indonesia, the biggest threat to REDD is
legal deforestation for agricultural purposes and biofuels. It is important to
keep this in mind. Food shortages and economic factors will directly affect the
success of REDD.
• A general conclusion from the above was that development pressures and markets
are going to have a significant influence over the success of REDD. If REDD
markets cannot compete with relevant commodity markets, they will not be
successful or their success will be limited.
• There should be a mechanism of punishment for those who participate and are
paid money to participate in REDD and are not abiding by the objectives of the
scheme.
• We need a holistic approach that looks at the market and development.
List of Participants’
| |
|
|
|
No |
Name |
Institution/Organization |
|
1 |
Abd. Rahman |
Forestry Departement of Peninsular Malaysia |
|
2 |
Aditya |
WWF |
|
3 |
Agus Sari |
Ecosecurities |
|
4 |
Andi |
Ekm |
|
5 |
Andy Roby |
DFID |
|
6 |
Anna C. Sinaga |
CIFOR |
|
7 |
Arief Rabik |
EBF |
|
8 |
Bambang Setiono |
CIFOR |
|
9 |
Charlotte V |
OCCES PNG |
|
10 |
Djoko S |
NRPD |
|
11 |
Elena Petkova |
CIFOR |
|
12 |
Farah Sofa |
Kemitraan |
|
13 |
Farida Zaitun |
Consultant |
|
14 |
Gabriel Eickhoff |
Forest Carbon |
|
15 |
Hari Priyadi |
CIFOR |
|
16 |
Henny Taslim |
Global Green |
|
17 |
Hugh Sreechk |
DFID |
|
18 |
J. Russel |
Kabar Media |
|
19 |
Joe Leimann |
World Bank |
|
20 |
Krystof Obidzinski |
CIFOR |
|
21 |
Laode M. Syarif |
Kemitraan |
|
22 |
M. Shishak |
US Embassy |
|
23 |
Marc PCP |
GCS |
|
24 |
Mubariq Ahmad |
WWF |
|
25 |
Nurcahyo Adi |
MFP |
|
26 |
R. Mud |
ESP |
|
27 |
Ratu Wina W |
FLEGT SP |
|
28 |
Rod Taylor |
WWF |
|
29 |
Rukmantara |
APRIL |
|
30 |
Sarah C |
Starling Resources |
|
31 |
Seiji Iwanaga |
IPB |
|
32 |
Siti J. Nooryasyini |
CIFOR |
|
33 |
Takeshi Tama |
FFPRI |
|
34 |
Togu Manurung |
Departemen Kehutanan |
|
35 |
Vincent van den Berk |
EC |
|
36 |
William Battge |
GERES |
|
37 |
Wirendro Sumargo |
FWI |
AFP
have more
Download Here