This project ended in November 2009. This website was last updated in June 2010. We have kept the website available for our readers' convenience. For information on CIFOR's current research, please click here.
Criminal Logging Hurts Climate and Jobs: US Report
Jakarta Globe, May 05, 2010
Illegal logging in this country, a leading timber exporter, is threatening jobs
in the US forest products industry and undermining efforts to use forests to
fight climate change, according to a report by US labor and environmental
groups.
The report, titled “Illegal logging in Indonesia, the environmental, economic
and social costs,” lists numerous steps the country has taken to curb illegal
logging but says much more must be done to end the corruption and demand that
drive the trade.
“Illegal logging undermines the strength and sustainability of the forest
products economy, both in Indonesia and the United States,” said the report by
the BlueGreen Alliance, Sierra Club, United Steelworkers, Rainforest Action
Network and the Natural Resources Defense Council.
The practice here and in other nations distorted global timber prices, undercut
sustainably manufactured products and jeopardized the jobs of US workers, the
report said.
“Under current conditions, there is no level playing field. Manufacturers across
the US are struggling to compete against imported, illegally harvested
low-priced wood and wood products,” it said.
Citing US Bureau of Labor Statistics, it says the logging, wood, paper and
cabinetry industries had lost 242,000 jobs, roughly 23 percent of their
workforce, since 2006.
US industry losses due to depressed wood prices and lost exports from illegal
logging had been estimated at more than $1 billion, the report added.
The authors called for steps to reform the harvest, trade and purchasing of wood
and wood products and said it was crucial that the United States was not
complicit in any illegal logging by allowing access to its markets by those
engaged in the practice.
“Trade and investment agreements should end demand for and trade in wood
products that are illegally and or unsustainably sourced,” it said.
For example, official recognition that non-enforcement of Indonesian forestry
laws was an unfair trade subsidy would also help curb illegal logging, the
authors say.
Indonesia has stepped up efforts to fight illegal logging and to curb
deforestation. Steps include banning the export of round and rough-sawn logs and
asking the Corruption Eradication Commission to investigate graft and
logging-related crimes.
But the report cites lax enforcement of existing forestry and anti-corruption
laws as hindering the fight against illegal logging and calls for much greater
transparency in tracking the origin of timber and timber products.
It also says the majority of logging in Indonesia was still illegal. Masyhud,
the spokesman for the national Ministry of Forestry, disagreed. “We admit there
is still illegal logging but it doesn’t mean all logging is illegal,” he said.
Deforestation is also a major source of greenhouse gas emissions. The National
Council on Climate Change has acknowledged that Indonesia is one of the world’s
top carbon emitters because of deforestation and forest fires.
The country’s tropical forests cover a vast area and rank only behind Brazil and
the Democratic Republic of Congo in Africa in area, acting like lungs of the
atmosphere.
The government has pledged to cut the growth of its greenhouse gas emissions by
curbing deforestation and promoting a UN-backed scheme that aims to reward
developing nations for saving their forests.
Projects that preserve and rehabilitate large tracts of forest can earn money
through the sale of carbon credits to rich nations trying to meet mandatory
carbon cuts at home. The money is meant to flow to project investors, local
communities and government.
But the report warned against a rush of investment into the scheme, called
Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Degradation, saying poorly designed
and managed projects could leave forests vulnerable to further destruction.
Reuters
ILEA has more