This project ended in November 2009. This website was last updated in June 2010. We have kept the website available for our readers' convenience. For information on CIFOR's current research, please click here.
Consultation Meeting Report: Law Enforcement and Investigative Audit in
Forestry Sector
Bulungan Room, CIFOR Office, Bogor
Friday, 23 October 2009, 09.00 – 15.00
Organized By CIFOR
Moderator: Anna Sinaga
Speakers: Bambang Setiono, Dwi Hartoyo.
Total participants: 12 people (list attached), representing KPK, BPK and PPATK
Opening and Introduction
Anna Sinaga
Anna opened the meeting by introducing ILEA team and invited the participants to
introduce themselves.
Later, Anna presented the overview of ILEA project and also the progress of the
study along with future plans. She also introduced the ILEA website that has
been developed since 2007. The website contains database and information related
to ILEA. This website is designed to be a tool for stakeholders to understand
and to implement integrated approach in curtailing illegal logging in Indonesia
Presentation 1
Bambang Setiono
Bambang presented the guidelines on using corruption and money laundering
approach in forestry crime especially illegal logging. This guidelines is
designed for the Law Enforcement Officers. Bambang explained how corruption and
money laundering are like two sides of a coin. There are some points from his
presentation, which are:
- Forest activities generally involve legal business activities, but the problem
is it is very complicated to divide the activities into legal and illegal. This
has been shown with many cases failed to prove the crimes in court
- The typologies of corruption in forestry sector consist of improper licensing
for timber exploitation, lack of supervision in timber and forest management,
involves legal wood-based companies concealing the origin of timber and criminal
activity in the forestry sector is related to the financial flow of the forest
business
- Regarding to licensing for timber exploitation and lack of supervision, there
are many gaps for corruption to occur because of the overlapping licences.
- The ILEA approach is focusing on asset recovery
- The guidelines can provide coordination amongst institutions (currently KPK,
BPK and PPATK)
Presentation 2
Dwi Hartoyo
Dwi delivered his presentation on the Guideline for investigative audit for
corruption in forestry sector. The guideline was based on the main duties and
function (tupoksi) from BPK, PPATK, KPK, National Police, especially from the
supreme audit board (BPK). He pointed out that if the forest loss can be located
and estimated then the auditor can directly do their investigation effectively.
He also explained how the investigative audit can support and supply information
for Police investigation. The investigative audit is conducted before the Police
investigation but it also has a role when investigation has conducted. The
crimes in forestry sector are like the iceberg phenomenon, what is visible on
the surface often does not reveal what actually happens. The illegal logging
activities often times involved bigger actors. The use of investigative audit
will be helpful to get to the higher target/main actors. This activity can
assist the law enforcement officers to work effectively. The auditors have
specific skills in financial investigation and they are familiar with business
process in forestry sector.
However the investigative audit also has weaknesses because the process of the
audit is conducted only in the beginning of the Police investigation and the
auditors have limited authority compared to the law enforcement officers.
Recommendations
For the guidelines on using corruption and money laundering approach in forestry
crime
- The cause of overlapping licenses in forestry business should be clarified in
typologies section.
- PEP should not focus only on forestry officers but also others state officers,
- Defining on which forest crime that should integrated to corruption
- Emphasizing on Coordination amongst institution to implement the guideline
- The coordination needs commitment from the higher level in each institution
therefore CIFOR should conduct a meeting with them to attain agreement in
implementing ILEA.
For the Guideline on Investigative Audit
- The guidelines should highlight something new in methodology that can be a
breakthrough for effective audit to support the investigation.
- The guidelines should include some of the international best practices so it’s
not too technical
- There should be more information/highlight about follow the money approach
General:
- In order to refine the guidelines so that the guidelines can be agreed amongst
relevant agencies, CIFOR should hold a workshop and inviting other law
enforcement agencies (the police and the state prosecutor)
- CIFOR could invite universities in refining the concept and resound the
guidelines
- Capacity development for judges (related to their mindset)
- Gain inputs from other institution like ministry of forestry in developing the
ILEA concept
CIFOR’s Respond:
- The investigative audit is also designed for the auditors in other institution
outside BPK (e.g inspectorate general in ministry of forestry, auditors in local
government)
- The guidelines will be refined by considering the recommendations from
participants
- Furthermore, the guidelines can be used in other countries (international) by
considering the legal system in each countries.
- We will develop a cooperation strategy to emphasizing coordination amongst
institution
List of Participants’
|
No |
Name |
Institution |
|
1 |
Sarjono |
The Supreme Audit Board (BPK) |
|
2 |
Agus Mulyana |
The Financial Intelligence Unit (PPATK) |
|
3 |
Said Imran |
The Financial Intelligence Unit (PPATK) |
|
4 |
Budi Santoso |
The Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) |
|
5 |
Emmie Wahyusundari |
The Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) |
|
6 |
Estika Permatasari |
The Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) |
|
7 |
Nanang |
The Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) |
|
8 |
Bambang Setiono |
CIFOR Consultant |
|
9 |
Dwi Hartoyo |
CIFOR Consultant |
|
10 |
Anna Sinaga |
CIFOR |
|
11 |
Sofi Mardiah |
CIFOR |
|
12 |
M. Zainal Arifin |
CIFOR |
|