








Background
Under its Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC), Indonesia has committed to reducing its greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions unconditionally by 26% by 2020, and by 29% by 2030 compared to a business-as-usual scenario. The Forest Reference Emission Level (FREL), which covers emissions from deforestation, forest degradation and peat decomposition, was set at 0.57 Gt CO2e yr-1 using 1990–2012 as reference period. It was submitted to the UNFCCC in 2016 and used as the benchmark for evaluating REDD+ performance against actual emissions during the 2013–2020 implementation period.
As Indonesia ranks among the world’s top holders of high-carbon reservoir in wetlands, peatlands and mangroves have been identified as major areas for FREL improvement and national MRV systems refinement for GHG accounting. Since wetlands were not accounted separately, there are some sources of GHG that are missing in the current FREL, including: (i) emissions from fires that do not lead to deforestation or degradation (ii) annual non-CO2 GHG emissions from drained peatlands, including CH4 and N2O emissions, and (iii) emissions from dissolved organic carbon (DOC). At the same time substantial missing sinks, including: (i) regeneration and natural expansion of mangroves, (ii) standing secondary forests sinks (mangroves, peatlands and non-wetland forests), and (iii) restored and rewetted peatlands will have to be accounted for.
To this end, assessment of the transparency, accuracy, completeness, consistency and comparability (TACCC) is deem necessary to comply with UNFCCC principles. Identifying underrepresented forest dynamics (sources/sinks) in Indonesian wetlands and consequently incorporating them would eventually improve FREL estimates.
Along this line this workshop is organized to facilitate the use and familiarization of the IPCC 2013 Wetlands Supplement. The dialogue will also allow participants to explore data mining and sharing from nationally and globally available sources for use in the proposed FREL improvement.
Goal and objectives
The overall goal of the workshop is to build the capacity of officials of the Government of Indonesia (GoI) in improving and developing FREL. Therefore, the workshop is designed to have a direct interaction and two-way communication with GoI officials with the following specific objectives:
- To familiarize with the IPCC 2013 Wetlands Supplement through hands-on sessions on the use and understanding of the Wetland Supplement for peatlands and mangroves by navigating through Chapter 2 (Drained organic soils), Chapter 3 (Rewetted organic soil), and Chapter 4 (Coastal wetlands) of the Supplement; and providing scientific background for some key EF (e.g. peat fire, peat decomposition) for a better understanding on how to develop Tier 2 EF.
- To present Transparency, Accuracy, Comparability, Completeness, Consistency (TACCC) principles of the UNFCCC to improve the existing FREL 2016
- To introduce Monte Carlo simulations to estimate uncertainty values for the FREL
Program
The program is designed to allow exchange of knowledge and experience among participants and facilitators/resource persons in the following areas:
- Data identification of data availability and gaps through diagnostic processes
- Methods: Presentation of IPCC guidelines (2013 Supplement on Wetlands) and introduction to uncertainty analysis (Monte Carlo)
Expected outputs
- Participants familiarize themselves with the IPCC 2013 Supplement on Wetlands
- Participants are aware of the gaps of data and information (missing sources and sinks) to improve the FREL following quality control and quality assurance (QA/QC) exercise
- Participants are well-equipped with methods and analytical capacity to further develop an improved FREL
Presentations
- Introduction
- Welcoming remarks
- Roadmap to 2nd FREL
- Peat emission factors: Navigating the IPCC wetland supplement
- Peat emission factors: Scientific background
- Mangrove emission factors: Navigating chapter 4 – coastal wetlands
- Mangrove emission factors: Scientific background on key emission factors
- FREL uncertainties estimates
- Description of TACCC principles
- Recommendations to better align FREL with the TACCC principles
- How best to support FREL improvement?
- Open discussions
- Monday
- Tuesday
- Wednesday
- Thursday
- Friday
Internet Connection and preparation
Vito Kaparang, CIFOR
Opening
- Introduction
Daniel Murdiyarso, CIFOR - Welcoming and opening remarks
Ruandha Sugardiman, MoEF - Roadmap to FREL 2020
Syaiful Anwar, MoEF
Session 1
Navigating Chapters 2 (Drained organic soils) and 3 (Rewetted organic soils)
Points of discussion:
- Peat emission factors used in the FREL 2016 and planned to be used in the FREL 2020
Kristell Hergoualc’h, CIFOR
Erin Swails, CIFOR
Session 2
Scientific background on some key emission factors (e.g. peat fire, peat decomposition) for a better understanding on how to develop Tier 2 emission factors
Points of discussion:
- Data availability and gaps
Kristell Hergoualc’h, CIFOR
Erin Swails, CIFOR
Session 3
Navigating Chapter 4 (Coastal Wetlands)
Points of discussion:
- Mangrove emission factors to be used in the FREL 2020
Daniel Murdiyarso, CIFOR
Sigit Sasmito, CIFOR
Session 4
Scientific background on some key emission factors (based on changes in above ground C stocks, belowground C stocks, soil C stocks, total ecosystem C stocks ) for a better understanding on how to develop Tier 2 emission factors
Points of discussion:
- Data availability and gaps
Daniel Murdiyarso, CIFOR
Sigit Sasmito, CIFOR
Summary and way forward
Rupesh Bhomia, CIFOR
Session 5
Description of options for estimating uncertainties under the IPCC 2006 guidelines
Points of discussion:
- What is needed to reduce uncertainty?
Oswaldo Carrillo, CIFOR
Session 6
Description of the process of compiling the data needed to run the Monte Carlo simulations
Running Monte Carlo simulations with Indonesian FREL data
Points of discussion:
- What is the acceptable uncertainty for an improved FREL 2020
- What at does it take?
Oswaldo Carrillo, CIFOR
Summary and way forward
Rupesh Bhomia, CIFOR
Session 7
Description of TACCC principles
Points of discussion:
- How TACCC diagnose can be used to improve FREL 2020
Zuel Araujo, CIFOR
Session 8
Diagnostic of how the existing FREL 2016 could be improved to better align with the TACCC principles
Points of discussion:
- What was in FREL 2016?
- What have to be there in FREL 2020?
Zuel Araujo, CIFOR
Summary and way forward
Rupesh Bhomia, CIFOR
Session 9
To understand how best to support the GoI in its FREL 2020 submission; particularly regarding the data needs and preferences and the accuracy requirements.
This would imply understanding on:
- The selected FREL emissions/sinks
- Preferences on how best to support GoI on the non-selected emissions/sources
- Description of the MRV system to support FREL 2020 submission
- Description of the FREL uncertainty estimates
Belinda Margono, MoEF
Session 10
- To understand the best way to request and access data from FREL 2016 and FREL 2020, so that diagnostics and improvements can be suggested and done for the next FREL submissions.
- To integrate the uncertainty analysis based on Monte Carlo Simulations and identifying focal points within the Government that can support hands-on collaboration to run these simulations.
Daniel Murdiyarso, CIFOR
Rupesh Bhomia, CIFOR
Kristell Hergoualc’h, CIFOR
Closing