Bhs.Indonesia print view

Home » Forest Indicators » Cases » Decision » Case Monitoring

This project ended in November 2009. This website was last updated in June 2010. We have kept the website available for our readers' convenience. For information on CIFOR's current research, please click here.

Position Case of Al Amin Nur Nasution

Defendant Identity:

Name    : H.M. Al Amin Nur Nasution, SE.
Position : Member of commission IV of DPR/PPP fraction/ PPP Party/voting area of Bengkulu
Address : Kompleks DPR RI Blok A5 No. 87 Kalibata, Jakarta Selatan

Case progress:

Al Amin Nur Nasution was arrested in the act receiving bribe from Azirwan, the secretary of Bintan regency at Ritz Carlton hotel on 8 April 2008. He was indicated serving as the liaison officer between commission IV DPR and Bintan regency in the case of change of function of protected forests to become city area in Bintan regency, Bintan Buyu, Bintan regency, Riau island.

The first court session Al Amin case was held on 26 August 2008, listening to the KPK public prosecutor charges. The court session of Al Amin case is held more than for Azirwan’s case because Al Amin is also involved in other [two] corruption cases.

The first case is allegation of extortion on two companies related to the procurement of forestry equipment at the Department of Forestry. The companies are PT Almega Goesystem and PT Data Script related to the procurement of GPS Geodetic, GPS Handheld, and Total Station at the Department of Forestry. Al Amin promised to help these two companies to win the project with some commission in return. In this extortion case Al Amin is assisted by M Ali Arsyad, Planning Board Secretary, the Department of Forestry as the authorized for budget use and commitment maker official.

The second cases is the same charges for Sarjan Taher and Yusuf Erwin Faishal, which is they allegedly received bribe for their role in smoothing the process of conversion of mangrove forest function in Air Telang village, Banyuasin regency, South Sumatera to become Tanjung Api-Api Seaport. This second cases involving Al Amin is filed in another court session.

Court Procedings:

In the initial court session the public prosecutor not only charged Al Amin in the same case involving Azirwan but also charged him with other corruption indictment which is extortion on two companies related to the procurement of forestry equipment at the Department of Forestry.

First charges: First charges is on the conversion of protected forest function in Bintan island. Primary charge of the first charges is that Al Amin violates article 12 a Act No. 31/1999 as amended to become Act No 20/2001 on Corruption Eradication in connection with article 65 point (1) of the criminal code. Whereas the subsidiary charge is that he violates article 11 of the Corruption Eradication Act in connection with article 65 point (1) of the criminal code.

Second charges: Al Amin was allegedly involved in an extortion activity on two companies in the forestry equipment procurement project at the Department of Forestry. Al Amin allegedly violates article 12 point e Act No 31/1999 on Corruption as amended with Act No 20/ 2001 on the amendment of Act No. UU 31/1999.

The public prosecutor in their indictment at the corruption court, Wednesday, 10 December 2008, to punish the defendant with 15 years imprisonment and Rp 500 million in fine or serve an additional six months in jail. The Public Prosecutor also demanded that the defendant to pay Rp 2.9 billion in restitution to the state and if he fails to pay the restitution it will add 2 year more in jail of the punishment.

Verdict:

The panel of judges of the Corruption Court [5 January 2009] decided that AL Amin found guilty of receiving bribery in exchange for agreeing to turn over protected forests for other uses and false promises to two companies involved tender at forestry department, as stated on Subsidiary Charge of First Charges and Second Charge. However the Panel released him from JPU indictment on Primary Charge of First Charges [as Al Amin is one of 50 member of Commission IV of House Representative, so his power practically very weak to herd the decision] .

The panel of judges sentenced the defendant to eight years imprisonment and fine of Rp. 250 million.

Al Amin decided to appeal to higher court

unfortunately, the appeal court, on their ruling at April 2, 2009, hold the first court's decision that Al Amin actively engaged on bribery process. But, due to his position as DPR member and women scandal, the appeal court lengthened the prison sentences to 10 years. The appeal court also upheld the first court’s order for him to pay a Rp 250 million (US$21,691) fine, or face an additional six months’ imprisonment. Additional to that, Al amin was ordered returning graft money amount of IDR 2.3 billion.

 

See others cases........