This project ended in November 2009. This website was last updated in June 2010. We have kept the website available for our readers' convenience. For information on CIFOR's current research, please click here.
Position Case of Azirwan
Defendant Identity:
Name : Azirwan
Position : Secretary of Bintuni regency, Riau Province, Riau
archipelago/Chairman of Bandar Seri Bintan Development Acceleration Team.
Case Progress:
Azirwan is the bribery perpetrator to the members of DPR commission IV
[Forestry and Agriculture Sector] from PPP fraction. The bribery was carried
out to accelerate the conversion of protected forest of 200 hectares out of
total 7.300 hectares in Bintan Buyu, Bintan regency, Riau island to become
Silih Bintan Seaport, the capital of Bintan island.
Total bribe money to Al Amin is Rp3,1 billion. The defendant himself was
caught red-handed doing bribery at the Ritz Carlton Hotel, Jakarta, 8 April
2008. The following day, 9 April 2008, Azirwan was declared as the suspect.
The bribery by Azirwan to Al Amin Nur Nasution was carried out several
times:
- On 2 December 2007, a total of Rp 100 million was handed over to Al Amin at
his house in Kalibata, South Jakarta;
- On 24 January 2008 Al Amin received some SGD 8.000 in the Shanghai Karaoke
Shanghai room, Borobudur Hotel, Jakarta;
- On 25 January 2008 some SGD 308.000 was paid in room 1630 of DPR building
[Al Amin’s office];
- On 8 April 2008, Azirwan paid out some SGD 154.000 in the Oak Room, Nikko
Hotel, Jakarta
- On 8 April 2008 evening at Mistere Pub, Ritz Carlton Hotel, Jakarta. A total
of SGD 30,000 from Azirwan was found and Rp. 3.9 million and Rp. 60 million
was found from Al Amin at the time of the capture.
This case is bribery case and not conversion of protected forest area
function to become non forestry for development purposes.
The conversion itself was
confirmed legal by the Minister of Forestry, MS Ka'ban.
On Monday, 30 June 2008, the first court session of the defendant was
held at the Corruption Court, Central Jakarta.
In this session Azirwan denied of bribing. On the other hand, he felt he
was extorted by Al Amin Nur Nasution, a DPR member. In his plea, Azirwan
stated that he was the victim of extortion and not the bribery perpetrator.
Charges:
The public prosecutor in their indictment at the corruption court,
Monday, 11 August 2008, to punish the defendant with 3 years imprisonment
and fine of Rp150 million and if he fails to pay the fine it will add 4 more
months of the punishment.
Primary Charges: the public prosecutor charged Azirwan with article 5 point
1 a Act No. 31/1999 in connection with Act No.20/2001 on the corruption with
minimum 1 (one) year in jail and maximum 5 years in jail [...giving or
promising something to civil servant or state administrator with the aim
that the civil servant or state administrator in question to do or not do in
his/her capacity against his/her obligation...]
Subsidiary Charges: the public prosecutor charged Azirwan with article 13
Act No 31/1999 in connection with Act No 20/2001 on the corruption
eradication with maximum 3 years sentence, [...Everyone giving present or
promises to civil servant considering his/her position or authority attached
to his/her position or capacity or by the present or promises provider is
considered attachment to the position or capacity...]
Verdict:
The panel of judges of the Corruption Court [1 September 2008]: decided
that Azirwan found guilty of carrying out bribery to Al Amin Nur Nasution, a
DPR member, as indicted by the KPK public prosecutor in their primary
charges. However, the panel of judges only sentenced the defendant to 30
months imprisonment and fine of Rp. 100 million or 3 months imprisonment.
Sources:
Azirwan Faces 5 years in jail
Amin’s bribery case court session to continue next week
Azirwan attends his
first trial
Azirwan: DPR who
asked the money
See others cases........