Bhs.Indonesia print view

Home » Forest Indicators » Cases » Decision » Case Monitoring

This project ended in November 2009. This website was last updated in June 2010. We have kept the website available for our readers' convenience. For information on CIFOR's current research, please click here.

Position Case of Drs. Marthen Renuw

Defendant Identity:

Name: Drs. Marthen Renuw Alias M. Reno
Date and Place of Birth: Mun, Tual, South East Mollucas (Maluku Tenggara) /06 February 1956
Occupation: Policeman [Police Commissioner]

Charges:

This case is very important for the effort to curb illegal logging as the defendant is indicted with multi charges: Corruption and Money Laundering, for the crime he did.

The case involving PT Marindo Utama Jaya and/or PT Senjaya Makmur that carried out logging activities or collecting timber forest product using heavy equipment without permit from the authorized official in the forest area of Bintuni-Manokwari, Papua. The defendant did not enforce the law to the perpetrator of forestry crime as the perpetrator has given the defendant bribe money of [ Rp. 1.065.000.000] to the defendant’s private bank account. In fact the defendant is a police official who has authority to conduct investigation on the perpetrator in question.

Upon the money he received, the defendant deliberately paid out or spent the money which is known or presumed as the result of criminal activity.

In the District Court of Jayapura, The Public Prosecutor accused the defendant with multi-charges.

Primary Charges [1]: The Defendant violates regulation stipulated in article 12 a Act No 31/1999 in connection with Act No. 20/2001 on Corruption Eradication in connection with article 64 point (1) of the criminal code
Primary Charges [2]: The Defendant violates regulation stipulated in article 3 point (1) c Act No. 25/2003 on amendment of Act No 15/2002 on Money Laundering in connection with article 64 point (1) of the criminal code.

And Subsidiary Charges [1]: The defendant violates regulation stipulated in article 12 B point (1) a Act No 31/1999 in connection with UU No. 20/2001 on Corruption Eradication in connection with article 64 point (1) of the criminal code. And More subsidiary Charges [1]: The defendant violates regulation stipulated in article 11 Act No. 31/1999 in connection with Act No 20/2001 on Corruption Eradication in connection with article 64 point (1) of the criminal code.

Subsidiary Charges [2]: The defendant violates regulation stipulated in article 6 point (1) b Act No. 25/2003 on amendment of Act No 15/2002 on Corruption Eradication in connection with article 64 point (1) of the criminal code.

Based these charges, the public prosecutor indicted the defendant with 3 years imprisonment and fine of Rp 50 million.

PT. Marindo Utama Jaya and/or PT. Sanjaya Timur itself has been under legal process over forestry crime by the Directorate Crime Investigation of Papua Police Office (Polda Papua), with suspect of Thing Chek Keng, Ting Sik Huang, Jingan Anak Ngaleh, Thomas Anak Labang, etc, while the fugitive suspects are Wong Sey King, Wong Sey Cau, and Wong Tsie Tung.

Verdicts:

According to the panel of judges of the Jayapura district court [on 9 October 2006], primary charges [1] consists of : [1] civil servant or state administrator; [2] receiving present or promises; [3] such present or promises is given to motivate to do or not do something in the position which is against his/her obligation; and [4] continuously. In his argument, the element of "receiving present or promises" is not proven in the court, as the transferred money is not a "present" but rather than a "debt" and thus is included in civil law scope. Therefore, the primary charges [1] is not proven.

It is the judge’s opinion on the status of the transferred money as a "debt" that eliminates all charges by the public prosecutor.

The subsidiary charges [2] consist of: [1] gratification; [2] civil servant or state administrator; [3] bribe if it relates to position and contradictory with obligation or tasks; [4] continuously carried out. In the judges argument, only element [1] and [2] are proven, while element [3] – which is an important element – is not proven, and thus gratification in the form of money received by the defendant is not categorized as bribe and thus this charges is not proven either. Neither is the more subsidiary charges.

On the second alternative charges for money laundering, both the public prosecutor and lawyers think that the defendant is not proven guilty of doing money laundering.

In the panel of judges’ argument, the defendant is not the predicate crime perpetrator which is the main element in article 3 point (1) c Act No 25/2003 in connection with Act No 15/2002 on Money Laundering. The element of "aims to hide or obscure the assets origin " is not proven either because during the court session no witness or evidences support the charges. The defendant, on the other hand, used the money, which is a loan, as operational fund of the Matoa Wanalaga – law enforcement operation in forestry crime. And thus the defendant should be released from the primary charges [2]. The judges also found the evidences and witness during the court session could not meet element of the subsidiary charges [2]. Therefore, the defendant should be released from the subsidiary charges [2].

Based on those facts and consideration, the panel of judges decided the defendant is not proven guilty for corruption and money laundering.

Upon the verdict of the panel of judges of the Jaya Pura district court, the public prosecutor appealed Kasasi to Supreme Court.

ILEA have analysis...

See others cases........