Sunderland T, Achdiawan R, Angelsen A, Babigumira R, Ickowitz A, Paumgarten F, Reyes-Garcia V and Shively G. 2014. World Development 64(S1):S56-S66.
This study is a product of the CIFOR-led Poverty and Environment Network (PEN). PEN is a collaborative global project investigating the linkages between forests and livelihoods. It collected and analyzed socioeconomic and environmental household-level data from 8000 households in 24 countries in Africa, Asia and South America.
The literature in gender and forestry is dominated by broad generalizations stating that men generally manage and use high-value cash crops, while women focus more on subsistence agriculture and forest product collection, primarily for consumption or other subsistence use. In addition, women are often believed to lack access rights to natural resources, and collect mainly under common property tenure regimes. There is also an accepted assumption that women possess limited decision-making opportunities. Using the household-level data generated by PEN, the research team analyzed gender differences in the access to forest products, collection and sale of forest products, as well as in community forest management, and came to some surprising conclusions.
While the generalization that women are the primary collectors of forest products seem to be true in Africa, data from South America indicates men dominate the collection of almost all processed and unprocessed forest products. In Asia, the burden seems to be shared quite evenly between men and women. The study shows that both sexes seem to collect predominantly for subsistence, and that men’s share and diversity of collected products is in fact generally higher than that of women’s.
In Africa, men utilized common property tenure regimes to a greater extent than women, and in South America, men dominated markets for forest products. We hope to challenge some of the conventional wisdom and generalities about gender roles in forestry and thus contribute to a more nuanced debate on the theme – gendered differences in forestry are not due to universal gender norms, but are rather highly contextual.
or visit http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0305750X14000692