Bhalla P.
The context of this study is the Forest Rights Act (FRA), passed in 2006 in India (that came into force in 2008), which legitimizes marginalized groups’ access to ancestral forested lands, promotes collective management of forests and provides tribal and other groups with the option of pursuing individual and community-owned land titles through the establishment of claims committees. Complementing existing research on the critical mass of women in decision-making, this qualitative case study, conducted in four districts of the southeastern state of Odisha, examines: ‘To what extent are critical actors and acts able to produce positive processes and outcomes for women in Odisha’s forest tenure reform process?’ Data collection took place at different intervals between February 2013 and March 2014 in the form of key individual interviews, focus-group discussions and participant observations. The units of analysis were the FRA claims committees, from the community level to the district level, which have a major stake in deciding which individuals and communities receive land-user rights.
The study finds that meaningful participation of women in the FRA claims committee process at the district, sub-divisional and village level was limited due to the State dominated forest tenure reform process, patriarchal strongholds (especially at the community level), and continued patterns of tokenism
in terms of female membership in the committees. Nevertheless, there are examples of better functioning FRA claims committees, especially at the village level, thanks to critical actors who consistently put women-friendly issues on the agenda and attempt to mobilize female committee members on a regular basis. Critical junctures such as the FRA amendment rules ensured that most FRC committees have one-third female membership exists; progressive leadership at the district magistrate level can create critical acts, leading to more positive FRA implementation outcomes for both men and women.
The study thus makes the following policy recommendations:
- At the national level, there is a need for another round of amendment rules to be issued, providing specific guidelines for the formation of claims committees. Specific recommendations include increasing women’s quotas within each committee, and rotating leadership of committees between men and women.
- At the State and district level, more lessons learned and best practices exchanges on the integration of women and other marginalized groups are needed.
- Increased consultations are needed within the nongovernmental sector on women’s role as critical actors and actors in the FRA process.
- NGOs should consult women in the community to understand what the customary land boundaries are, whether there are any female claimants that have been left out, and what type of future strategies they have for forest management, protection, biodiversity and dealing with negative interference from external actors. It is also important to involve them in project work as much as possible.
- Finally, we must place more emphasis on process versus outcome developments in future research, which addresses women’s meaningful participation and their role in forest tenure reform processes. Further research on key critical actors and critical junctures is needed in order to understand when and how enabling factors are created.