Women’s participation in forest management: A cross-country analysis

Published

Coleman EA and Mwangi E. 2013. Global Environmental Change 23:193–205.

The paper examines what determines women’s participation in forestry institutions and the effects of women’s participation on institutional outcomes (particularly on levels of conflict and fairness of rules). The paper draws on a theoretical framework developed by Bina Agarwal (2001) which suggests that the following six factors explain women’s participation in forest governance: (i) rules that exclude entry of women into the participatory process; (ii) social norms such as segregation, division of labor or gendered biases; (iii) social preferences that give more weight to men’s participation than women’s; (iv) entrenched claims by men who are hesitant to give power to women; (v) few personal endowments of property or social networks that would allow effective participation from women, and; (vi) household endowments or attributes that prevent effective participation (such as caste position or social status). The analysis is based on a detailed household survey conducted with 1433 households in Bolivia, Kenya, Mexico and Uganda and a more aggregated data set from forest associations investigated by the International Forestry Resources and Institutions (IFRI) program in 10 countries.

The results show that women’s participation is likely when institutions exist that are less exclusionary, when households have more education, and when there is a low level of economic inequality in general and across genders in particular. The study found that a history of women’s participation, especially when women are seated on forest councils or hold leadership positions, is correlated with less disruptive conflicts.

At the individual level, the data implies a need to increase women’s access to education and skills. At a more aggregated level, institutional support to reduce the gender gap is necessary. Supply-side interventions that target gender bias in selection of council members and their leaders can help to increase the proportion of women serving in councils and as leaders. However, because barriers may originate from discriminatory attitudes and practices that are rooted in cultural norms (and not only the design of institutions), the provision of training, skills, and information for both men and women may be required.

However, the multiple pathways through which women’s participation may translate into better institutional, economic and social outcomes for women in forestry settings still require more attention and empirical verification.

To learn more about this project, contact  Esther Mwangi, e.mwangi@cgiar.org
Top