One book, two events, many thieves
- Content:Global data set and global analyses update
- Science workshop and policy conference update
- New PEN book: ‘Methods for research and fieldwork’
- Good readings from Bolivia and Brazil on community management and thieves
- PENROACH: Sharing and saving files
1. Global data set and global analyses update
Version 1 of the aggregated PEN global database, comprising 29 case studies, was released in February this year. More studies have been added since, and we anticipate that the results presented at the final conference in London will be based on 36 case studies, based on data from 8000 households.
Besides the regular checks for typos, gaps and inconsistencies, the database has been improved in several ways: missing prices have been estimated, based on village prices; income for households that missed one quarter has been calculated based on seasonality and income in other quarters; and adult equivalents were defined. Some large partner data sets have been split into several more homogenous sites, meaning the global database has about 55 sites.
We would like to use this opportunity to thank all the PEN partners, without whom this herculean task would not have been possible!
2. Science workshop update

The aim of the workshop is to bring together researchers to present papers for potential inclusion in the planned special issue of a high-level journal, in which the PEN global results will be published. Following a public call for abstracts, which closed on 1 March, more than 30 abstracts were selected from an overwhelming volume of submissions (about 170), a testament to the interest in this research topic. In addition to 6 presentations of PEN global results, the final line-up for the workshop includes 9 PEN partner presentations and 17 non-PEN presentations. When invited guests and observers are included, we will have 55 workshop participants representing 15 nationalities. Presentations encompass 7 main themes related to forest–poverty links:
- Forest livelihoods and dependence
- Inequality and differentiation
- Shocks, fluctuations, and safety nets
- Land tenure and local institutions
- Markets and marketing
- Deforestation and reforestation
- Conservation development tradeoffs.
The workshop will also provide a forum to discuss research methods and key priorities for future research on forests and livelihoods, and to identify policy implications to feed into the policy conference in London that immediately follows.
For more information, go to: /pen/pen-science-workshop.
Conference update

Preparations for the 1-day policy conference are shaping up nicely, with many confirmed attendees and a now complete programme of high-level presenters. In addition to presentations of results from the PEN global study by CIFOR scientists, there will be presentations from:
- Frances Seymour, Director General of CIFOR
- Tim Wheeler, Deputy Chief Scientific Advisor and Deputy Director, Research and Evidence Division, Department for International Development, UK
- Mike Speirs, Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark, Danida
- Bill Adams, Professor of Conservation and Development, Cambridge University
- Arun Agrawal, IFRI Coordinator and Professor at the University of Michigan
- Kathleen Beegle, Senior Economist, World Bank Development Research Group
- Kate Brown, Professor at the University of East Anglia
- Edmund Barrow, Regional Forest Advisor Africa, International Union for the Conservation of Nature
- David Kaimowitz, Director of Sustainable Development, Ford Foundation
The climax of the day will be an interactive panel discussion on policy implications, moderated by John Hudson, a member of CIFOR’s Board of Trustees, with 6 experts from a range of disciplines and backgrounds.
The purpose of this conference is to help put the environment more realistically onto the poverty agenda, and to strengthen the case for systematic data collection on the ways in which poor people use environmental income. For updated programme information, and to register for the remaining seats, click here: /pen/pen-policy-conference.
3. New PEN book: ‘Measuring livelihoods and environmental dependence: Methods for research and fieldwork’
Thousands of surveys on rural livelihoods in developing countries are conducted every year. Unfortunately, many suffer from weaknesses in method and problems in implementation. Quantifying household dependence on multiple environmental resources such as forests, bush, grasslands and rivers is particularly difficult and often simply ignored in these surveys. The results therefore may not reflect rural realities.
The ‘hidden harvest’ from natural resources is too important to livelihoods for development research, policies and practice to ignore. Fieldwork using state-of-the-art methods, especially well-designed household questionnaires, becomes an imperative to adequately capture key dimensions of rural welfare. This book describes how to do a better job when designing and implementing household and village surveys for quantitative assessment of rural livelihoods in developing countries.
The book draws heavily on PEN experiences, and is a major output of the PEN project. Seventeen of the 19 contributors to the publication have been involved in PEN as partners or resource persons. The book deals with the entire research process from vague research ideas, formulation of specific hypotheses, data needs, design of surveys and questionnaire, data collection, data management and analysis to presentation of results; it is enriched by numerous practical examples from the field. The book should provide an invaluable guide to methods and a practical handbook for students and professionals.
Arild Angelsen, Helle Overgaard Larsen, Jens Friis Lund, Carsten Smith-Hall and Sven Wunder (eds) 2011 Measuring livelihoods and environmental dependence: methods for research and fieldwork. London: Earthscan. http://www.earthscan.co.uk/?tabid=102458.
‘This volume provides an invaluable guide to the relationship between poverty, environment and how people benefit from natural resources.’ K. Brown
‘This book shows how researchers can do it [household income surveys] right.’ D. Kaimowitz
‘This book provides a solid methodological foundation for designing and implementing household and village surveys.’ B. Campbell
‘This brilliant collection of analyses will have a lasting impact.’ A. Agrawal
4. Good readings: community management and theft in Bolivia and Brazil
Two fresh publications by PEN partners Patricia Uberhuaga and Amy Duchelle (and their coauthors) study two different aspects of devolution and community forest management in Bolivia and Brazil.
Uberhuaga et al. looks at the forest management plans in their study area of Cochabamba, Bolivia. Official recognition of an indigenous community area transfers subsistence use rights to the community, while commercial use require an officially approved forest management plan. The technical requirements for these management plans and their annual operational plans are quite elaborate; they also require marketed forest products to have a certificate of origin and a statement of destination. Given the low value of the resources transferred, commercial forest use has failed to become a major cash source for the communities. The forests in the three case areas are left unexploited, at risk of clear-felling for agriculture, or the timber is illegally harvested by a few local inhabitants. Nevertheless, these reforms have strengthened local land claims and indigenous identities, which may support future local changes to forest regulations.
Duchelle et al. looks at another side of local forest use in Pando, Bolivia; and Acre, Brazil. Devolution of forest rights can support local livelihoods but also generate conflicts, which can express themselves as theft of forest resources. Brazil nuts are the dominating non-timber forest product in the area. They are frequently lost through theft, particularly in Bolivia, which has a more recent and top-down process of formalising communal land rights. About 50% of the households in the Bolivian sample reported nut theft during one year, compared to 10–15% in Brazil. About half of those households thought that members of their own community had done it. The Bolivian case estimates a loss of 22% of the combined harvest, equivalent to USD 700 per household per year. Obviously, the thieves gain a similar amount to their own annual household income, but the authors conclude that the general threat of nut theft ‘locks collectors into a management regime that is clearly dangerous and inefficient, and perhaps detrimental to long term viability’: Bolivian harvesters must collect the nuts as soon as they fall from the trees to avoid losing their valuable crop to others.
Uberhuaga, P., Larson, H.O., Treue, T. 2011 Indigenous forest management in Bolivia: potentials for livelihood improvement. International Forestry Review 13(1):80-95. http://www.atypon-link.com/CFA/doi/abs/10.1505 /ifor.13.1.80?journalCode=ifor.
Duchelle, A.E., Cronkleton, P., Kainer, K.A., Guanacoma, G., Gezan, S. 2011 Resource theft in tropical forest communities: implications for non-timber management, livelihoods, and conservation. Ecology and Society 16(1): 4. http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol16/iss1/art4/.
Cloud computing: Computing in which services and storage are provided over the Internet, or cloud http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/cloud_computing
Two common problems facing today’s researcher are sending, sharing and saving files. In most cases, email will suffice, but there are limit on the size of files that email applications can easily manage: from a miserable 1MB to Gmail’s generous 25MB. And these limits cut both ways, for senders and receivers.
Saving data is another problem. As external hard-drive prices plummet, backing up has never been cheaper. But even external hard drives fail, are lost or get stolen. Sometimes our back-ups fail because they are in the same place as the main data. What are some solutions for these problems?
For sending and sharing, www.yousendit.com is probably the most popular. It allows you to send files and folders of up to 2 GB for free, and more if you subscribe. Or you can use www.dropbox.com. Dropbox also gives you 2 GB of space free (up to 100 GB by subscription), but this 2 GB is real space in the sense that you have a 2 GB folder on your device where can drop in documents and data. If you work on multiple devices (e.g. a work computer, a home computer, a netbook, and a smart phone), dropbox allows you to synchronise files across all your devices ensuring you can always access the latest versions.
Spideroak (https://spideroak.com/) has the same features as Dropbox, but you need not reorganise your filing system as you do with Dropbox. Simply tell Spideroak which folders you want to backup/share and it will do the rest. The PENroach is using Spideroak and loving it.
Happy syncing.
Arild Angelsen, PEN coordinator, arild.angelsen@umb.no
Ronnie Babigumira, PEN research fellow, r.babigumira@cgiar.org
Nicholas Hogarth, PEN partner and consultant, n.hogarth@cgiar.org

These two PEN-based background reports (


