PENews 2/2005

CONTENT:

  • PEN takes off
  • guidelines available
  • dramatic differences with shorter recall periods
  • Good Reading: do you POLEX?
  • Ririn tells her secret story from Kalimantan.

1. PEN FIELDWORK TAKES OFF

Since the first PENEWS, PEN fieldwork has really been taking off. Four data-collections have started (Ririn Purnamasari – Indonesia, Julius Tieguhong Chupezy – Cameroon, Miriam Wyman – Belize, Manyewu Mutamba – Zambia), and another 6-7 will start over the next couple of months. French and Spanish translations of the PEN questionnaire are available on the PEN Web, and a Portuguese version will appear soon. I’m regularly contacted by potential new PEN partners, and feel very confident that we will reach the target of 20 PEN studies across the tropics. That will make PEN the comprehensive global investigation into the poverty-forest link which we all hope for – in addition to 20+ excellent case studies.


2. THE TECHNICAL GUIDELINES AVAILABLE

All sections except one of the PEN technical guidelines are now available on the PEN Web page:  here

The guidelines include the list of codes to be used in the prototype questionnaire. Another important section concerns PEN definitions of forests and other land categories. These should be studied carefully.

Codes and definitions – and the PEN questionnaire itself – are like tattoos: they are hard and painful to change once made. But for the other parts of the guidelines we welcome comments and suggestions for improvement. We expect the guidelines to be updated regularly.


3. IS IT WORTH IT? YES!

PEN wants to set a new and higher standard for household data collection. A key element is short recall periods through the quarterly income surveys, which obviously is more costly and time consuming. Is it worth it?

Baikuntha Aryal, a PhD student at the Norwegian University of Life Sciences who also attended the first PEN workshop in Bogor in 2004, tested this. He used three survey formats in his work in Nepal in 2004-5: (1) A monthly survey with one week recall period, (2) a quarterly survey with one month recall, and (3) an annual survey with 12 months recall. The quarterly surveys gave an estimated income 56-80 % higher than the annual survey for the three main groups of forest products. The monthly survey estimates were 75-108 % higher than the annual ones.

Thus the short answer is: YES! The accuracy increases dramatically by shortening the recall period. Most of the gain (roughly 80 %) is by going from annual to quarterly surveys, the PEN survey format. Surprisingly, the difference between the various survey formats was largest for timber, possibly due a more ‘selective memory’ for illegal activities such as timber harvesting.


4. GOOD READING: Do you POLEX?

POLEX is CIFOR’s electronic mailing list, which is sent to more than 14 000 forest interested individuals around the globe. See (also for previous POLEX messages): http://www.cifor.cgiar.org/docs/_ref/polex/index.htm

As a subscriber, you will get about two messages per month. Each message includes a 500 word summary of some recent research document with information on how to obtain the document and contact its author. If you would like to receive CIFOR-POLEX in English, Spanish, French, Bahasa Indonesia, or Nihon-go (Japanese), send a message to Ketty Kustiyawati at: k.kustiyawati@cgiar.org


5. PEN PROJECT: Ririn S. Purnamasari: “Deforestation Dynamics in Indonesia”: Project description and some preliminary fieldwork experiences.

“What factors cause Indonesian small-scale farmers to deforest? In particular: does high forest dependency lead to less forest clearing? Data to address this question are being collected through a survey of 263 rural households in six villages in East Kalimantan province. The survey is designed as a follow-up of the Indonesian Economic Crisis survey conducted by CIFOR in 1999. The sample households consist of the original sample households from the 1999 CIFOR survey that still can be found, plus new sample households drawn among newly formed and in-migrant households.

After completion of the village census in early August 2005, the first round of household surveys started. The qualitative village survey was conducted during the period of the census through focus group discussion with key informants in the village. We found that having such discussions at an early stage was useful for developing relationship with village residents which will then somehow influence the smoothness of the interview in the household surveys.

The experience from interview processes showed that while on one hand we should ask questions to respondents systematically, on the other hand it would be useful to indirectly repeat some questions to check consistency of their answers as well as to get complete information. This is particularly important in relation to some sensitive questions like land holding, land clearing, income and expenditure. It is often worth to let respondents describe their answers at length which then often indirectly lead them to disclose some information on other questions that they hadn’t properly answered previously. For example, several times when we asked respondents about their income from forests, they would mention income only from main forest product rather than from entire range of products collected. We would later find other sources of income when they described how they spend their time in the forests.

Now the data entry is finished and tabulating the results has started. Much care has been already taken in data cleaning and editing, so hopefully there would be no big surprises found later. Meanwhile, the team is also preparing for the second round of the quarterly survey. Hopefully, the respondents will be more forthcoming in revealing sensitive information as they would already know the enumerators better.”  

Finally, I wish you a relaxing holiday season, and a happy new 2006 (not forgetting the Ethiopians, Nepalese, Chinese and others using other calendars). 

Best regards,

Arild Angelsen                 

PEN Coordinator 

Funding Partners

Top