CONTENT:
- The database is ready
- the last batch of PENNERS on board
- tattoos can be changed & new questions welcomed
- money-money-money
- “what is your question?” how to really measure impacts
- Mutamba asks if urban markets can reduce rural poverty
- warns against static planning, bad roads and unforeseen marriages!
1. PEN ACCESS DATABASE FOR DATA ENTRY
The database for entering PEN household and village data is finalized and available at: here. It is developed in MS Access by Ronnie Babigumira and Betty Abang, who have done a great job in making it an easy to use and questionnaire look-alike format. This should greatly facilitate data entry and reduce errors. Many PEN partners have added or will add sections to the PEN prototype questionnaire. If you are familiar with MS Access, you can do the necessary additions in the database yourself. But, DON’T change the format (including variable names) in the existing database; that will mess up things when data are compiled in PEN’s global data bank. If you are NOT familiar with MS Access, Ronnie and/or Betty can tailor-make the database. Just send your questionnaire to ronnie.babigumira@umb.no Questions (after you have read the manual!) and comments (bugs etc.) can also be sent to Ronnie.
2. COPENHAGEN WORKSHOP
The workshop in Copenhagen on 15-16 May – the third and final one for new PEN partners – was attended by 9 potential PENNERS. A very nice group with a good geographical distribution, enabling some gap filing on South Asia and Latin America for the overall coverage of PEN studies (still West Africa is the weak region – suggestions for new PENNERS are therefore welcome). Although there is some funding uncertainty for a few of the 9 participants, I expect most – possibly all – to become full PEN partners.
3. TATTOOS AND 2nd ROUND OF ANNUAL HH SURVEY
We have earlier noted that a questionnaire is like a tattoo – once made, it’s hard and painful to change it. Well, that’s not 100 % true for PEN. One of the nice things by having 4 rounds of household surveys is that you get a second chance. In particular, the second annual household survey can be used to add new questions that you discovered during fieldwork. For example, you have learned that credit-savings groups play an important role in the local economy, and you would like to ask all the households if they are members. Thus you should during the fieldwork collect a few questions that may be added to your 2nd annual household survey.
This is also true for the PEN prototype questionnaire of the 2nd annual household survey. We welcome suggestions for additions and changes in this questionnaire. Are there any gaps that need to be filled that you have discovered during fieldwork? Please send your suggestions to arild.angelsen@umb.no by 1st August.
4. MONEY, MONEY, MONEY
PEN started without the big pot of money to run the project until the bitter end (2010). But with a strong faith in the research idea and the PEN way of (net)working, and a belief that good ideas eventually get external funding. In June-July, PEN in cooperation with various universities have sent 3 large applications to support workshops, establishment of the global data bank, and research time for coordination, supervision, support and analysis. Let’s keep our fingers crossed!
We also congratulate 3 IFS applicants for PEN studies who got a conditional green light: Charles Jumbe (Malawi), Ajith Chandran (India), and Marie Ndiaye (Senegal). Another 3 did not reach the finals, yet we should be happy with the overall result.
5. WHAT IS YOUR QUESTION?
In principle, writing a paper – or a PhD thesis – is quite simple: you have a question, and you answer it! Well, in practice it is a bit more than that; in particular, you have to use scientific methods to answer the question. But the bottom line is: a good paper (or thesis) almost always has a good research question and a clear and well-argued answer to that. It makes it so much more fun to read, and it also provides a good guide for the research (what is relevant and what is not?). As a Master and PhD theses supervisor I now routinely demand that the first paragraph of the thesis/paper should have a question. So, the simple question is: WHAT IS YOUR QUESTION?
6. GOOD READINGS: IMPACT EVALUATION
Many PEN studies will have questions of this type: “what is the impact of x on y?” You want to evaluate a programme, a policy, or some phenomenon, e.g., local forest management, ecotourism, a forest protection area, or a tree outgrower scheme. As a development economics textbook notes: if you think this is easy, it’s because you have not understood it. Fortunately, such impact assessments or evaluations are classical problems, and some good brains have thought about the issues. The World Bank’s home page on poverty impact evaluation gives a good overview, and has a couple of very nice and useful papers by Martin Ravallion, a leading expert on this: “Evaluating Anti-Poverty Programs” & “The Mystery of the Vanishing Benefits: An Introduction to Impact Evaluation”. You’ll find both at: http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/TOPICS/EXTPOVERTY/
EXTISPMA/0,,menuPK:384336~pagePK:149018~piPK:149093~theSitePK:384329,00.html
The site and papers discuss issues such as sampling and selection biases, as well as methods to assess impacts such as propensity scores. (Note: The World Banks’s general poverty web-site also contains a number of useful tools for measuring and analyzing poverty.)
Another nice paper on evaluation and impact assessment – more on the conservation side – is by Ferraro and Pattanayak (2006). “Money for nothing? A call for empirical evaluation of biodiversity conservation investments”, available at:
http://biology.plosjournals.org/archive/1545-7885/4/4/pdf/10.1371_journal.pbio.0040105-L.pdf
7. PEN PARTNER PROJECT: MANYEWU MUTAMBA: TAPPING URBAN MARKETS: ELEVATING THE ROLE OF MIOMBO WOODLANDS IN RURAL POVERTY REDUCTION (part 1)
Elevating the role of forests in rural livelihoods beyond subsistence and safety net functions towards poverty reduction has proved to be a daunting challenge. Can the growth of vibrant urban markets for forest products due to high rates of urbanization across Africa offer livelihoods opportunities through forest based development? Do the real poor in rural communities have the capacity to deal with the more complex urban market chains given their severely constrained material resources, low levels of education, lack of access to reliable information and the social capital that one often requires to navigate amongst more powerful players? Using household and market level data collected from two contrasting sites in Zambia, this study will answer these questions and provide insights into the conditions under which poor forest dependent households can significantly benefit from tapping urban markets.
The dominant feature of the landscape in both study sites are the vast tracks of miombo woodland, punctuated by stretches of open grassland on the plains. Forest resources play a central role in people’s livelihoods. Wood fuel provides energy for most households while a wide range of non-timber products that range from honey, mushrooms, fruits, medicinal plants, thatching grass and game meat are extracted for subsistence use and sale. In Mufulira, charcoal sold in nearby towns and on the roadside is regarded as one of the highest cash income earners for households. Kabompo district is renowned as the source of high quality organic honey which fetches good prices on the export market. The district with its largely virgin miombos is also a source of high value hardwood timber that is mostly exported to South Africa. With cropping and livestock playing very limited roles in the local economies due to cultural and financial constraints there is no doubt that forests in the two sites form the core of people’s livelihoods.
8. MANYEWU MUTAMBA: FIELDWORK, PLANNING, SURPRICES AND MARRIAGE (part 2)
After my three rounds of the PEN survey I want to share some of my experiences, hoping that others will find this useful in minimizing surprises and bad decisions. It’s mostly about things that I would have done differently (or I shouldn’t have done!) and also about those things that one cannot run away from. Good planning and preparations – and hopefully some good tips – can help one minimize the level of damage (and give you the feeling that ‘you are not alone’).
Getting work started in completely new surroundings is always going to be a major challenge and test of character, it can get worse if one is doing it for the first time! In most cases it’s about the people, the language, the culture, the geography, the power politics, the protocols, etc. Just getting to understand how things function in different places is a slow and sometimes frustrating process. Naturally some people are shy, reserved, quiet, lethargic etc., but for purposes of the PEN survey one would rather do without any of these as all progress directly depend on the amount of energy one puts at every stage. No doubt getting out of ones’ little shell can be a rather painful endeavour but its worth trying for a couple of months!
For me the single biggest mistake was what I now call a static plan. In fact the second lesson is that a wonderfully detailed plan is not good enough, having sufficient flexibility and adaptability is probably more important. Here is a good example: my travel logistics were based on conditions prevailing at the start of the survey, with little thought of how seasonal changes during the survey year would affect the plan. By the second round of the survey I was spending double the amount of time travelling to sites as road condition deteriorated with the onset of rains. Fuel requirements also went up significant as I needed four-wheel traction for much of the distance. When I thought I had seen the worst another shocker was on its way, the local currency appreciated by up to 40% within a period of 3 months, stretching my shoe-string US Dollar budget to breaking point! In the field one of my best enumerators found a marriage offer too attractive to postpone and had to join the new husband in another province! PEN surveys – like life itself – are far from completely predictable. You should plan for that.
———–
For those residing on the Northern Hemisphere, I wish you a good summer. I will extend mine by 12+ months by moving to Australia and Perth for a year from mid July. That should give more time for all the exciting PEN work ahead.
Warm regards,
Arild Angelsen
PEN Coordinator
These two PEN-based background reports (


