Two new successful PEN funding applications
CONTENT:
- Updates
- New kid on the block
- Danida PEN project
- USAID PEN project
- Good readings on conservation vs. development (a never ending story…)
- Three PEN studies in Bangladesh explore the role of traditional Village Common Forests, alternative agroforestry systems, and marketing information systems and entrepreneurship.
1. UPDATES
* Since the last PENEWS (June 2007), a few more PEN partners have started fieldwork or will start very soon: Marieve Pouliot in Burkina Faso, Shiba Kar in Bangladesh (see presentation below), Barry Ferguson in Madagascar, and Sandra C. Tapia and Jamie Cotta in Brazil. Riyong Kim is set to start her work in Dem. Rep. of Congo. Later this year, PEN studies will kick off in Ghana, Cambodia and Burkina Faso as part of the Danida funded project (see below). This will bring the total number of PEN studies to more than 35.
* CIFOR/PEN Scientist Brian Belcher has recently relocated from Indonesia to Canada, where he has taken up the post of Director at the Centre for Non-Timber Resources at Royal Roads University in Victoria, Canada. Brian had been at CIFOR for 10 years, is a founding member of the PEN core team, and previously led a global comparative study of forest products commercialization. Brian will remain a CIFOR Associate Scientist and will maintain his involvement with PEN from his new location.
* To date, three PEN data sets have been submitted (Belize, Malawi and Guatemala). A dozen more are expected over the next 2-3 months. Contrary to their expectations, many have found data entry to be very time consuming. It is therefore strongly recommended that data entry be started in the field concurrently with the survey work.
* The planning for the upcoming PEN workshop in Barcelona 8th – 12th January 2008 is going well. The first three days will focus on the fieldwork experiences and the forthcoming thematic and global analysis, while the last two days will be a training workshop in data management and analysis of the individual data sets.
2. (Almost) new kid on the block: Ronnie Babigumira
Ronnie Babigumira (34) has been appointed the new CIFOR (PEN) research fellow. Ronnie, who has worked on the development of the PEN databases, will be continuing with this to establish and manage the PEN global database and the subsequent data analysis. He will also participate in the overall PEN coordination and management, and advise PEN partners on data management and analysis. Ronnie, who is from Uganda, got his Master degree in agricultural economics from Makerere University in Kampala. He is currently finishing his PhD thesis on Space, Poverty, and Land Use in Uganda at the Norwegian University of Life Sciences. Ronnie started working part time in the position on 1. October, and plan to move to the CIFOR HQ in Bogor, Indonesia in March 2008.
3. Danida-funded PEN project
The Danish Research Council will support a four year PEN based research project with more than 5 million Danish kroner (approx. USD 1 mill.). The project will use the PEN methods for extensive fieldwork and data collection in Cambodia, Ghana and Burkina Faso, countries from which there is only one PEN study at present. In addition, the project includes support for PEN’s central operation at CIFOR. The Danish funding therefore nicely complements the DFID (UK) funding secured earlier this year.
Project activities and fieldwork will start very soon, with a successful inauguration workshop held in Ghana on 26th – 28th October. The workshop focussed on the PEN research methods, and on identifying cross-cutting themes in the three countries. One such topic concerns tenure and decentralization of forest management. The project is led by Carsten Smith Olsen of Copenhagen University, while the country coordinators are Beatrice O. Darko of the Forest Research Institute of Ghana, Boureima Ouédraogo of the University of Ouagadougou, and Neth Top of the Cambodia Development Research Institute.
4. USAID-funded PEN project
USAID, through the BASIS AMA CRSP programme, will support a four year PEN related project entitled “Natural Capital and Poverty Reduction” with USD 600 000. The activities centre on strengthening host-country capacity for policy analysis and deriving policy lessons regarding two topics: (i) the role of natural insurance among the rural poor, including the degree to which environmental income serves as a safety net; and (ii) the potential for poor rural households to use environmental income to accumulate physical and human capital, and move out of poverty.
The project will focus on two countries, Malawi and Uganda, and strongly involves the two PEN partners in those countries (Charles Jumbe and Pam Jagger), but will also include additional and complementary data collection. The principal investigators of the project are: project coordinator Gerald Shively (Purdue University), Arild Angelsen (CIFOR and Norwegian University of Life Science), Monica Fisher (Oregon State University), Charles Jumbe (University of Malawi, Bunda College), and Dick Sserunkuuma (Makerere University.
5. Good reading: Conservation vs. development (a never ending story ….)
The conservation vs. development debate is among the eternal questions for both development and environmental researchers. Do we have to choose between the two? And if yes, how should we balance them? Although we cannot find the ultimate answer, two recent review articles shed some new light on this relationship: David Kaimowitz and Douglas Sheil (CIFOR) remind us in an article in Biotropica 39 (5) that to the poor “biodiversity is about eating, staying healthy, and finding shelter”. They argue for a “pro-poor conservation” approach, conserving species useful to local communities rather than the rare and charismatic ones. Kai M.A. Chan et al. in Conservation Biology 21 (1) discuss whether the conflict between people’s needs and biodiversity is real. Many valuation studies have emphasized the overlap between conservation and supply of services, but “this reflects the need for proofs-of-concepts before ivory-tower ideas can take root on the ground”. They also stress that the category “people” have little meaning and must be disaggregated to be meaningful and understand the distribution of costs and benefits of conservation efforts.
The two articles can be downloaded from:
* Conserving What and for Whom? Why Conservation Should Help Meet Basic Human Needs in the Tropics
by David Kaimowitz and Douglas Sheil
BIOTROPICA 39(5): 567–574 2007
* When Agendas Collide: Human Welfare and Biological Conservation
by Kai M.A. Chan et al
Conservation Biology Volume 21, No. 1, 59–68
C2007 Society for Conservation Biology
6. PEN PROJECT 1: Khaled Misbahuzzaman: Conservation Practices and Livelihood Strategies of the Village Common Forest Communities in Chittagong Hill Tracts (CHTs), Bangladesh
This study is being conducted in two of the three hill districts in Bangladesh where indigenous communities maintain Village Common Forests (VCFs), locally known as ‘mouza reserves’. These communities continue to apply good traditional principles and practices of resources conservation, rarely seen elsewhere in the country, in spite of pressure from changing livelihoods. The basic research questions of this study are:
* What critical relationships exist between the traditional conservation practices and changing livelihood strategies?
* What role does community indigenous knowledge play in response to changing needs of conservation and livelihood and how do these changes affect this knowledge?
* Can VCF management play a model role in sustainable forest management in the CHTs?
The survey is being conducted in VCF communities (10 and 3 villages in Rangamati and Banderban districts, respectively). In addition, the study also includes neighbouring non-VCF households for comparative purposes. In each village approx. ten households were randomly selected and interviewed using a pre-tested structured questionnaire. Additional information was collected from informal meetings with residents and interviews with the village headmen.
Communities are actively conserving perennial water sources. These water sources not only meet their water requirement but also supports other resources management practices in the households and in their farms. Massive environmental degradation in the CHTs and increasing external influences from the development workers have had mixed effects on the livelihood strategies of the communities. Many VCF communities in Rangamati district have alternative livelihood opportunities other than those centred around VCFs. Some of them are inclined to transfer the management of and the benefits from the VCFs to the Buddhist Monastery. In Banderban, on the other hand, most livelihood activities are still centred around the VCFs.
PEN PROJECT 2: Syed Ajijur Rahman: Sustainable forest management for poverty reduction through agroforestry options in the uplands of Eastern Bangladesh
The main research interest is to assess the local dependency on forest resources and tree crops, in a context where forests are under pressure from number of factors, notably, high population growth, commercial timber production and most importantly, shifting cultivation. The latter practice is the dominant agricultural system in this area, and is a major cause of deforestation. The research will also try to assess the role of agroforestry in sustainable forest management with a view to contribute to the scientific basis for scaling-up agroforestry such that it may contribute to more sustainable forest management in the uplands of Eastern Bangladesh. The research results will be used to suggest and promote appropriate agroforestry options that would contribute towards this end. The project combines institutional, social and micro-economic research.
This project has three main objectives:
* To identify and assess forest dependency of rural households, including the role of forest income as safety net and possible pathways out of poverty.
* To explore the symbiosis between smallholder forest cultivation, agroforestry, and shifting cultivation, and on that basis identify number of optimal agroforestry systems for sustainable forest management and increased local forest benefits.
* To explore how agroforestry adoption reduces the pressure on natural forests, or whether the causality mainly runs from forest and resource scarcity to agroforestry adoption.
Two villages in Khagrachhari District in the uplands of Eastern Bangladesh have been selected for the study, with 50 households in each being selected for interviews using the standard PEN format. Additionally, 40 agroforestry cultivators have been selected to identify the actual and envisaged costs and benefits of alternative agroforestry systems.
Field work started late last year. The biggest challenge has been serious financial constraints. I was therefore delighted to learn that PEN would be supporting my work (with the icing on the cake being that I got the news on my birthday!). There were also some challenges finding good enumerators and some language difficulties. However these have all been overcome and work is progressing well. In general, the households have been very hospitable and responded well to the questions.
What have I learnt so far? Both villages are very remote and most people are really poor. There is significant forest loss, but also some recovery from plantations in the shifting cultivation fields. One potential agroforestry model has been identified, combining natural forest species (Dipterocarp trees, Acacia mangium, Litsea sp., shrubs and bamboo), with fruit trees (jackfruit and mango), and crops (upland rice, maize, pineapple and beans).
PEN PROJECT 3: Shiba P. Kar: Commercialization of Non-wood Forest Products in Bangladesh: A Focus on Rural Livelihood Development
In Bangladesh, like many other countries, people depend on Non-wood Forest Products (NWFPs) for their food, shelter, fuel, fodder for livestock, medicine and other uses and this trend continues in some regions. However, this sector is overlooked and discounted in national level forestry programs. Moreover, rural people who collect and sell these resources are deprived a true price of NWFPs given the lack of market information and access to supply chains. Since NWFPs play an important role in the daily life and economy of the rural population in Bangladesh, domestication and commercialization of NWFPs would be an effective way to utilize the full potential of these products for rural livelihood development.
This research project will concentrate on one main research question: How can a marketing information system and entrepreneurship development lead to sustainable utilization and conservation of NWFPs and encourage commercialization of the products for improved livelihoods of rural forest-adjacent people? The two broad objectives of the study are: (1) to identify the prospect and constraints of existing marketing supply chains and information systems in NWFPs trade and to investigate potential marketing strategies for NWFPs that would encourage sustainable trade and resource conservation, (2) to explore appropriate approaches for NWFPs related small-scale entrepreneurship development within the forest-adjacent communities for their improved livelihoods.
To answer the research question, this study will collect data from Chittagong Hill Tracts (CHT) of Bangladesh which is situated at the southeast corner of the country. These hilly forest regions are dominated by indigenous peoples and the majority of the population depends on NWFPs directly or indirectly for household consumption or cash.
To familiarize myself with the study area, a reconnaissance visit is planned. During this visit, meetings with resource persons, key informants, organizations working in the area and other stakeholders will be held to discuss and gather information on NWFPs. Based on the primary information and data on NWFPs and their relevance to the possible study, 2-3 species (such as bamboo, cane, medicinal plants) with high economic and conservation values will be selected to investigate the prospects and potential of the commercialization of them. Two most concerned sites will be selected and 3 – 5 villages in each districts either in clusters or random will be taken into account.
This will be followed by a detailed household survey using a detailed pre-designed questionnaire (a draft is being prepared now along with PEN prototype questionnaire and will be finalized after field testing and adapting to the sites). The survey will be conducted on 50 to 150 randomly selected households from each site (considering 3-5 villages in each site) and will have questions on NWFPs collection, production and marketing potentials relating rural livelihoods. A separate questionnaire will be used to gather information and collect data on markets of selected NWFPs involving entrepreneurs, buyers and sellers in different stages of markets.
Best regards,
Arild Angelsen
PEN coordinator
These two PEN-based background reports (


